The recent enactment of a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in Uttarakhand has reignited the debate on the need for a uniform set of laws governing personal matters in India. Proponents view this move as a step towards secularism and gender equality, while critics argue that meaningful progress must begin with reforming existing Hindu personal laws. Key areas such as inheritance, guardianship, and divorce laws within Hinduism are often criticized for perpetuating inequalities. Before enforcing a UCC, it is imperative to address these internal inconsistencies to ensure that any uniform code truly upholds principles of justice and equality. This nuanced approach is crucial to avoid mere assimilation and instead foster a system that genuinely promotes fairness for all citizens. The discussion around the UCC is not just about legal uniformity but also about rectifying historical injustices embedded within personal laws. By prioritizing reforms within Hindu personal laws, India can pave the way for a more credible and effective implementation of a Uniform Civil Code that reflects the values of a diverse and inclusive society.